Pro-tip: if a manuscript is catalogued as containing ‘extracts from Isidore of Seville’s Etymologies’, check if it really is that. Years ago, in a couple of related manuscripts in the Biblioteca Laurenziana in Florence, I found that a text described as ‘mostly from Isidore’ was actually a Lombard revision of Irish computistical and cosmological material… Continue reading Finding Lost Texts in Plain Sight
What did it mean to be a person in the Middle Ages who had a ‘profound ignorance of nature’? Neil deGrasse Tyson recently commented about how the word ‘disaster’ was ‘prescientific’ and pertained to a time when ‘misfortune was commonly blamed on cosmic events’. This was illustrated by the famous image of people standing amazed… Continue reading ‘A Profound Ignorance of Nature’
A couple of weeks ago I had the pleasure of leading a week of the Reading Group for our Institute of Transnational and Spatial History. They had been discussing how they had not had any engagement with writing about premodern history, and my week was their second go at changing that. This was great for… Continue reading Talking Global Again
How bad was the state of learning in the Merovingian kingdoms? It is hard to say. Something I want to do in my present work on the Merovingian worlds is to be more positive than some scholars like to be. But there is a problem: the problem of loss. In a recent study, Ian Wood… Continue reading The Lost Civilisation of the Merovingians
You might remember I wrote a little post about a Carolingian list of eclipses from 812 and a ‘mystery eclipse’. It was a strange list because lots of the dates were out a little bit because they had been adjusted to fit with standard lunar tables. It was also surprising because some eclipses mentioned definitely… Continue reading Unexpected Ptolemy at the Carolingian Court?
What do you want from a historical label? This Autumn there has been a lot of talk about whether the term ‘Anglo-Saxon’ should, on the whole, be put aside. [There are different recent takes here Mary Rambaran-Olm and Michael Wood]. Surely: yes. The history of the modern English word is firmly rooted in early modern… Continue reading Responsible Labelling
“In 731, the great monastery founded by Columbanus at Luxeuil was raided by Arab horsemen. Those monks who could not escape were put to the sword.” So writes Tom Holland in his new book Dominion: The Making of the Western Mind. It is part of a section on the great ‘Clash of Civilisations’, the Christian… Continue reading Was the Arab Destruction of Luxeuil (731) Made Up?
I spent much of this week at a wonderful conference in Erlangen on Gog and Magog legends, hosted by the generous Georges Tamer and his team. The legends of Gog and Magog are one of those ‘memes’ (as Anna Ayşe Akasoy called them) that have relevance in many different Jewish, Islamic, and Christian traditions. One… Continue reading Gog and Magog: Crossing Boundaries
How did early medieval writers who engaged with “science” deal with issues of authority? Last week I wrote a post about how the early medieval Church did not “suppress” efforts to understand the natural world in rationalised ways. Religion did not mean that people thought everything was structured by mystery magic. This week Jo Edge… Continue reading Paradigms and Authority in Early Medieval Astronomy
It is commonly stated that science was “suppressed” in the Middle Ages by the Church. By later standards, there were definitely few giant leaps in technology or theory. The explanation often given is that science was too problematic for an age of faith, as it raised uncomfortable questions about Creation, miracles, and cosmology in general.… Continue reading The “Dark Ages” Didn’t “Suppress Science”